Home / Blogs

A Programmer's Perspective on the IANA Transition

Steve DelBianco

Earlier this week, I posted from Singapore on the challenges we face in designing the transition of IANA functions from the US government to the global multistakeholder community. Now, let's consider how a programmer would design new mechanisms to accomplish this transition.

For starters, a programmer would need something more than high-level principles. Coding requires use cases for routine interaction and especially for cases where users don't follow the expected routine and where the real world intervenes with inconvenient problems.

For non-programmers, here's an analogy: It's a good principle to practice safe driving in winter weather. It's a use case to prepare for and respond to a specific situation, such as having your car begin spinning sideways on a snow-covered highway.

Knowing the array of possible use cases helps us anticipate worst-case scenarios and design appropriate responses, regardless of whether those scenarios ever actually occur.

Today, ICANN is an effective organization that generally performs its core functions, so it can be uncomfortable to imagine a scenario where a future ICANN fails dramatically or is confronted with a serious threat. But that's what we must do to design and develop mechanisms that will ensure ICANN's accountability and stability into the foreseeable future.

And that's where use cases come in. Let's consider worst-case scenarios and develop mechanisms that would resolve those scenarios in a way that's at least as effective as the admittedly crude mechanism we have today — where the US government ensures a stable root if the IANA contractor can't, and where the threat of losing the IANA contract keeps ICANN accountable to its global stakeholders and the public interest.

At ICANN's Singapore meeting this week, I suggested a few use cases that the community should address in designing for transition of IANA functions and ICANN accountability:

  • What happens if ICANN cancels the Affirmation of Commitments, which it can do with just 120 days notice? Or if ICANN fails to implement recommendations of an Affirmation review?
  • What happens if ICANN deliberately escapes legal presence in a nation where users, registrants, and contract parties need to seek legal remedies?
  • What happens if ICANN becomes financially insolvent?
  • What happens if ICANN approves a specific change to the root that could threaten its stability and security?
  • What happens if governments advise ICANN to remove TLDs from the root in order to suppress dissent and free expression?

This last use case is unfortunately more plausible than fanciful, if you go by comments made by Chinese and Iranian governments at yesterday's meeting between the GAC and the ICANN Board. Both expressed deep skepticism about the multistakeholder process and dissatisfaction with the power of governments. Our use cases should help us test whether the mechanism we develop can respond to protect the multistakeholder model from those who would usurp it.

You can reasonably argue that today's IANA contract includes nothing to respond to any of the use cases listed here. But we all know that the influence of the IANA contract award extended far beyond its functional limitations. Remember 2012, when the US government canceled the IANA bid process because ICANN's bid did not meet the higher performance standards? If you look, you'll clearly see the leverage of the IANA contract decision in enforcing the only external accountability that ICANN has: the Affirmation of Commitments.

If the Affirmation is to remain part of the new ICANN accountability framework, as most of us expect it will, it's essential that the leverage formerly conveyed by the IANA contract be replaced with a new mechanism.

Let's establish the right use cases as part of the process to design new accountability mechanisms, and we'll end up with something that will answer to the threats and challenges we're likely to face in the real world.

By Steve DelBianco, Executive Director at NetChoice. More blog posts from Steve DelBianco can also be read here.

Related topics: ICANN, Internet Governance, Regional Registries


Don't miss a thing – get the Weekly Wrap delivered to your inbox.


New mechanism Kevin Murphy  –  Mar 31, 2014 8:02 AM PDT

Great post, Steve.

Nice to see the problem broken down like this.

I'm curious: what "new mechanism" would you recommend?

To post comments, please login or create an account.

Related Blogs

Related News

Explore Topics

Dig Deeper

Afilias Mobile & Web Services

Mobile Internet

Sponsored by Afilias Mobile & Web Services


Sponsored by Verisign

DNS Security

Sponsored by Afilias

Promoted Posts

Now Is the Time for .eco

.eco launches globally at 16:00 UTC on April 25, 2017, when domains will be available on a first-come, first-serve basis. .eco is for businesses, non-profits and people committed to positive change for the planet. See list of registrars offering .eco more»

Industry Updates – Sponsored Posts

Leading Internet Associations Strengthen Cooperation

i2Coalition to Present Tucows CEO Elliot Noss With Internet Community Leadership Award

Michele Neylon Appointed Chair Elect of i2Coalition

2016 U.S. Election: An Internet Forecast

Afilias Chairman Jonathan Robinson Wins ICANN's 2016 Leadership Award at ICANN 57

MarkMonitor Supports Brand Holders' Efforts Regarding .Feedback Registry

Domain Management Handbook from MarkMonitor

US Court Grants DCA Trust's Motion for Preliminary Injunction on .Africa gTLD

United States Court Has Granted an Interim Relief for DCA Trust on .Africa gTLD

Dyn Weighs In On Whois

Season's Greetings - 2015 End of Year Message from DotConnectAfrica

"The Market Has No Morality" Sophia Bekele Speaks on Business Ethics and Accountability

Dyn Comments on ICG Proposal for IANA Transition

Independent Review Panel Favored DotConnectAfrica Trust Against ICANN Ruling Over .Africa Domain

TLD Security, Spec 11 and Business Implications

ICANN Business Constituency Elects Elisa Cooper of MarkMonitor as Chair

ICANN's Registry Audits Begin Next Week. Are You Prepared?

DotConnectAfrica on "CONNECTing the Dots: Options for Future Action" at UNESCO, Paris

IBCA Presentation to ICANN GAC on Protection of Geographic Names in New gTLDs

Season's Greetings - 2014 End of Year Message from DotConnectAfrica