Home / Blogs

ICANN Takes a Wrong Turn on New TLD Contracts - "Post Signature Revision Process?"

Jonathan Zuck

The pen is mightier than the word...or should be. When ICANN Chairman Peter Dengate-Thrush --­ an accomplished attorney — said last year that he wouldn't let one of his own clients agree to a contract that could be unilaterally changed after it was signed, the Internet community breathed a sigh of relief.

But when the Chairman backed away from that stance earlier this week in Nairobi, it became clear that we should have held our breath a little bit longer.

ICANN's Draft Applicant Guidebook (DAG) is the bible for companies and organizations seeking to launch a new top-level domain. The latest iteration of the DAG, released last year, included a provision that would allow ICANN to summarily rewrite the terms of its contracts with new domain operators, even after those contracts are signed.

Members of the community roundly criticized the proposal ­ which turns the fundamental covenant of a contract on its head, and has ramifications that extend far beyond prospective operators of new domains. When Dengate-Thrush signaled his own concern with the provision, many assumed that it was well on its way to being removed, or at the very least replaced with something more reasonable.

This week, however, the Chairman backed away from that position, saying that ICANN would need the flexibility to make changes to already-singed registry contracts. This has the potential to be a serious blow, not just to new registry operators, but also to clarity, contractual compliance and due process throughout ICANN.

Contracts form the backbone of ICANN's larger compact with the global Internet community. The subject of contracts, and of contract enforcement has been a repeated theme in the larger discussion of accountability and transparency within the organization.

On the eve of a critical review of ICANN's transparency and accountability, it would send a terrible message if ICANN were to take a giant step away from contractual certainty and fairness.

ICANN is under great pressure to finalize the DAG and launch the new TLD round, but this is an issue that cannot be overlooked. The community has spoken through the bottom-up process, and has said in a clear voice that this contractual provision is unacceptable. Even the most fervent proponents of the new TLD round cannot wish for a contractual obligation that can be changed at ICANN's whim.

The place to address this is here in Nairobi. ICANN needs to send a clear signal that it understands the community's concerns, and will work quickly to develop a contractual structure that is fair to all.

With any luck, new registries won't have to consider Dengate-Thrush's extremely sound legal advice, and not sign.

By Jonathan Zuck, President of Association for Competitive Technology (ACT). More blog posts from Jonathan Zuck can also be read here.

Related topics: ICANN, Internet Governance, Top-Level Domains

 
   
WEEKLY WRAP — Get CircleID's Weekly Summary Report by Email:

Comments

To post comments, please login or create an account.

Related Blogs

Related News

Explore Topics

Industry Updates – Sponsored Posts

MarkMonitor Takes a Look at Progress on New gTLD Program in Latest Report

Priority Access Program for Verisign's First IDN New gTLD, .コム

Minds + Machines Group Expands Into Chinese Market

Dyn Weighs In On Whois

New .PET Domain Sunrise Period Begins January 19

Minds + Machines Adds .boston to geo-TLD Portfolio

.CO Hits 2 Million Domains as Premium Sales Surge

Season's Greetings - 2015 End of Year Message from DotConnectAfrica

Neustar's Career Site Launched Under Its Own Branded TLD: 'careers.neustar'

Radix Closes Holiday Sales With Over 35K Paid Registrations

Another Tech Leader Joins .tech

Radix's .ONLINE Fastest to Sell 100,000 Domains

.PRO Domains Now Available to All

The ".law" Domain Gains Momentum Throughout the Legal Profession

Portfolio Update: October Launches and Renewal Rates

"The Market Has No Morality" Sophia Bekele Speaks on Business Ethics and Accountability

We're Moving Forward. You Coming?

City of Miami 3rd in U.S. to Launch Dedicated TLD

Internet Grows to 296 Million Domain Names in Q2 2015

Dyn Comments on ICG Proposal for IANA Transition

Sponsored Topics