Home / Blogs

Are the FCC Workshops Fair?

Richard Bennett

The FCC has run three days of workshops on the National Broadband Plan now, for the purpose of bringing a diverse set of perspectives on broadband technology and deployment issues to the attention of FCC staff. You can see the workshop agendas here. The collection of speakers is indeed very diverse. As you would expect, the session on eGov featured a number of government people and a larger collection of folks from the non-profit sector, all but one of whom has a distinctly left-of-center orientation. Grass-roots devolution arguments have a leftish and populist flavor, so who better to make the argument than people from left-of-center think tanks?

Similarly, the sessions on technology featured a diverse set of voices, but emphasized speakers with actual technology backgrounds. Despite the technology focus, a good number of non-technologists were included, such as Dave Burstein, Amazon's lobbyist, Paul Misener, and veteran telephone regulator Mark Cooper. A number of the technology speakers came from the non-profit or university sector, such as Victor Frost of the National Science Foundation, Henning Schulzrinne of Columbia University and IETF, and Bill St. Arnaud of Canarie. The ISPs spanned the range of big operators such as Verizon and Comcast down to a ISPs with fewer than 2000 customers.

Given these facts, it's a bit odd that some of the public interest groups are claiming to have been left out. There aren't more than a small handful of genuine technologists working for the public interest groups; you can practically count them on one hand without using the thumb, and there's no question that their point of view was well represented on the first three days of panels.

The complaint has the feel of "working the refs" in a basketball game, not as much a legitimate complaint as a tactical move to crowd out the technical voices in the panels to come.

I hope the FCC rolls its collective eyes and calls the game as it sees it. Solid policy positions aren't contradicted by sound technical analysis, they're reinforced by it. The advocates shouldn't fear the FCC's search for good technical data, they should embrace it.

Let a thousand flowers bloom, folks.

By Richard Bennett, Senior Research Fellow. More blog posts from Richard Bennett can also be read here.

Related topics: Broadband, Law, Net Neutrality, Regional Registries

WEEKLY WRAP — Get CircleID's Weekly Summary Report by Email:

Comments

Ah, a sour grapes letter Suresh Ramasubramanian  –  Aug 13, 2009 8:04 PM PST

Thanks for sharing that.

Sascha Meinrath was allowed to participate Richard Bennett  –  Aug 13, 2009 11:52 PM PST

His comments at the mobile wireless session on European hobbyist networks were quite entertaining, although not particularly serious. Claiming that “hub-and-spoke” networks are less scalable and efficient than wireless meshes is not credible. See the video at: http://www.fcc.gov/realaudio/mt081309b.ram

To post comments, please login or create an account.

Related Blogs

Related News

Topics

Industry Updates – Sponsored Posts

DotConnectAfrica Delegates Attend the Kenya Internet Governance Forum

Ofcom Benchmarking UK Broadband Performance Welcomed, But Needs Considerable Improvement

Neustar Chief Technology Officer Appointed to FCC's Technological Advisory Council

INTA 2013: Gearing Up for Dallas

Thomson Reuters to Acquire MarkMonitor

Neustar Labs Innovation Center Grand Opening (Video)

How Secure is Your Mobile Network? And Does It Even Matter? (Webinar)

Neustar and University of Illinois Launch the Neustar Innovation Center

Nominum Launches World's First Purpose-Built Suite of DNS‐Based Solutions for Mobile Operators

Afilias Says "No" to SOPA

Minds + Machines to Announce New .brand gTLD Pricing at INTA

.CO Recognized Alongside Industry Giants in Trademark Industry Awards

Verisign and Coalition for ICANN Transparency, Inc. ("CFIT") Resolve Litigation

MarkMonitor to Co-Chair International Anti-Counterfeiting Coalition Spring Conference

Q4 2010 Fraud Intelligence Report

AusRegistry Int. and Crowell & Moring Join Forces to Support New Top-Level Domain Applicants

MarkMonitor Report: How Scammers Generate Significant Traffic Promoting Suspected Counterfeit Goods

Report Sheds Light on Scale and Complexity of Online Piracy and Counterfeiting Problem

Acquisition Extends Anti-Piracy Capabilities for Digital Content

How Targeting Luxury Brands Online Results in Significant Traffic for Online Scammers

Sponsored Topics

Verisign

Security

Sponsored by
Verisign
Afilias

DNSSEC

Sponsored by
Afilias
dotMobi

Mobile

Sponsored by
dotMobi
Minds + Machines

Top-Level Domains

Sponsored by
Minds + Machines