Home / Blogs

An Update on the Closed Generics Debate

Mary Iqbal

ICANN is currently seeking public comment on the subject of "closed generic" Top Level Domain (TLD) applications. A "Closed Generic" is a TLD that is a generic term, but domains within that TLD will not be sold to the public.

There are those who object to generic terms such as .book being operated as closed registries, which means that domain names within the .book Top Level Domain as proposed by Amazon would not be sold to the public, but instead, Amazon.com would own and operate all domain names within the .Book Top Level Domain. (e.g. You might soon be able to navigate to Amazon.book.) For example, Google, Inc., has applied to create the .Search TLD to allow it to improve its search functionality, and Amazon.com has applied for the .book TLD to allow it to segregate its book product offerings onto a separate TLD. Many oppose these projects because, it is said, that these TLDs offer companies like Google, Inc. and Amazon.com an "unfair competitive advantage".

On the other hand, there are those who believe that Closed Generics should be permitted because they do not represent an unfair competitive advantage. By way of comparison, the leading bookseller online is Amazon.com, not Book.com. Those who support Closed Generics are in favor of innovation and competitive freedom, with no restrictions on the types of services that can be provided through a Top Level Domain.

To date, there have been 42 comments submited to ICANN's public comments section:

2 Commenters Support Allowing Closed Generic Top Level Domains
39 Commenters are Opposed to Closed Generic Top Level Domains
1 Commenter is Opposed to the current gTLD Application Process all together

View a comment summaries at:
http://www.getnewtlds.com/news/UpdateOnClosedGenericsDebate.aspx

By Mary Iqbal, Founder of DotAnything.co

Related topics: ICANN, Internet Governance, Top-Level Domains

WEEKLY WRAP — Get CircleID's Weekly Summary Report by Email:

Comments

Good comment, bad finale Rubens Kuhl  –  Mar 03, 2013 1:00 PM PDT

Hi Mary.

I liked most of the comment "Get New TLDs Inc." posted in the public forum, as it was based on how a self-regulated industry should operate alongside law-based ones like Trademark Law.

I just need to take exception for the mention to name.space, one of what I call "root terrorists" ; name.space, Unified Root and the others compose a very different line of thinking that is incompatible with the ICANN mandate to defend the public interest.

They are free to argue the value of their services, and they indeed made comments on the appropriate public comment forum, http://newgtlds.icann.org/en/program-status/comments . Let's keep them there and not mix up those discussions.

Point well taken Mary Iqbal  –  Mar 03, 2013 1:10 PM PDT

Point well taken - Mary

Error page George Kirikos  –  Mar 03, 2013 2:12 PM PDT

The link to the comment summaries goes to an error page: "Server Error in '/' Application. The directory '/App_Code/' is not allowed because the application is precompiled."

Have you sent an alert to ICANN Rubens Kuhl  –  Mar 03, 2013 2:17 PM PDT

Have you sent an alert to ICANN communications on this ?

Re: Error page Ali Farshchian  –  Mar 03, 2013 2:20 PM PDT

It appears that currently the entire site under getnewtlds.com is down!

The site is down for a scheduled Mary Iqbal  –  Mar 03, 2013 2:26 PM PDT

The site is down for a scheduled build. 

Thanks!
Mary

Please visit again! Mary Iqbal  –  Mar 03, 2013 2:51 PM PDT

The site is back up.  Thanks for visiting GetNewTLDs.com!

Sincerely,
Mary

To post comments, please login or create an account.

Related Blogs

Related News

Topics

Industry Updates – Sponsored Posts

.Host Announces Top Global Players As Pioneer Partners

Public Interest Registry Releases Bi-Annual Report, .Org Domain Registrations Pass 10.4 Million

Public Interest Registry to Speak About Upcoming Launch of .ngo and .ong Domains for NPOs

Landrush Opens for .Website, .Press and .Host

Afilias Announces General Availability of .BLACK Top-Level Domain

Last Lap of .WEBSITE, .PRESS and .HOST Sunrise

DotConnectAfrica Trust Responds to ICANN 50 GAC Advice, Updates on .Africa Application IRP Status

New .ORGANIC Domain Sunrise Begins, Creating Verified Space 
for Organic Products and Services

Non-English "IDN Email" Addresses Are Finally Working!

TLD Registry to Speak at Inaugural World Domain Day India

Independent Endorsement of Dot Chinese Online & Dot Chinese Website

ICANN London Recap Webinar

Four Reasons to Move from .COM to Your .BRAND Domain

DotConnectAfrica Delegates Attend the Kenya Internet Governance Forum

Neustar to Launch usTLD Stakeholder Council

Introducing the New .ORGANIC Domain: A Trusted, Credible Space for Organic Products on the Web

.WANG - 15,000 Registrations on Day One of General Availability

Dot Brand: Why Your Brand Needs Its Own Top-Level Domain

Afilias Announces Start of .BLACK Sunrise Period

Radix Launches Three New TLDs in Sunrise With Backing from 50+ Registrar Partners

Sponsored Topics