Home / Blogs

A Tempest in a Libyan Teapot

John Levine

The .LY domain is Libya, and their government recently cancelled the registration of the short and snappy VB.LY, provoking great gnashing of teeth. If you direct your attention to the address bar above this page, you'll note that it's at JL.LY, equally short and snappy. The .LY registry started allowing two letter second-level domains last year, and there was a quiet land rush. Now they restrict those domains to people actually in Libya, but say they'll let us keep the ones we have. How concerned am I that they'll take my domain away, too? Slightly, but not very.

Honestly, it was pretty foolish to put a sex site on a domain in a Muslim country. VB is Violet Blue, a very elegant high class sex site, but there's no way it's anything else. She argued that VB.LY was only a redirector to underlying sites and had no sexual stuff on it, which may have been technically correct, but it was utterly obvious to anyone what showed up on your screen if you typed http://vb.ly in the address bar. I think Violet Blue is swell, but it is naive to imagine that the Libyan government would not feel differently once they noticed it.

Every two-letter top level domain is a assigned to a country or country-like geographic area, known as a ccTLD. The rule that countries own their ccTLDs is far older than ICANN. Even though the US government has always had its thumb on the DNS root, they have been notably silent as domains for Cuba, North Korea, and Iran have been delegated and redelegated. ICANN has told me that they reserve the right to refuse to make a change to a ccTLD, but they never have done so. My impression is that they engage in polite negotiations when a ccTLD asks to do something technically ill-advised, so they don't exactly refuse, but they don't exactly make the change, either. It's clear they only would flatly refuse to prevent serious technical problems.

In the agreements it has with some ccTLDs, ICANN doesn't ask countries to do anything beyond some non-binding requests to notify each other if something of interest to the other party comes up, and sometimes for the countries to make token contributions toward ICANN's expenses. One correspondent asked why ICANN doesn't demand fuller disclosure of the policies, but what would be the point of asking? ICANN's only recourse would be to pull the plug on a ccTLD and they're not going to do that.

VB claimed to be unaware that she was violating Libyan laws, which is probably true. But the world is a big place, and the US is only part of it. Libyan laws are in a hard to read foreign language, but foreign countries are like that. (Libyans presumably have the same complaint about US laws, which are not written in easy to read Arabic.) I don't think it takes a profound understanding of world culture to be aware that .LY is in Libya, Libya is a Muslim country, and Muslim tradition encourages modesty and forbids alcohol, so a site which features pictures of scantily clad women holding drinks isn't going to work.

Although it can seem hard to believe at this point, domain names are intended to be stable identifiers, not fashion accessories. In most countries, people register in their country domain, so Canadians register in .CA, in .MX, French in .FR, and so forth. An ill-advised policy prior to 2002 required that all .US domains contain city and state, e.g. IBM.ARMONK.NY.US, so we all used .COM instead, but that's unique to the US. If you live in Libya, .LY works fine, and you wouldn't be doing anything contrary to Libyan law anyway.

Here's a thought experiment: let's say someone lives in Denmark, where pictures of 17 year olds are considered legal erotica, and builds his web site. He registers a domain for it in .US or .GU or .AS or .PR or .VI or .MP, where US law considers those pictures child pornography. How long would the domain last? Would it matter that he didn't know, or that he couldn't read the English fine print? Same issue.

I also have the short and snappy SP.AM which I got in 1999, by politely asking the university that ran .AM at the time. I don't see any danger of it going away, but I do realize that Armenian law applies, and I don't read Armenian. Ditto my much newer JL.LY, which I use for my blog — they might take offence and take it away, so I do have other US-based domains just in case.

By John Levine, Author, Consultant & Speaker. More blog posts from John Levine can also be read here.

Related topics: DNS, Domain Names, Registry Services, ICANN, Internet Governance, Law, Policy & Regulation, Top-Level Domains

WEEKLY WRAP — Get CircleID's Weekly Summary Report by Email:

Comments

nic.ly's statement is worth reading. And so are its policies. Both in english Suresh Ramasubramanian  –  Oct 10, 2010 7:47 AM PDT

Violet Blue doesn't need to read Arabic at all.

Nic.ly - the .ly ccTLD operator - has a statement on this incident at http://nic.ly/anvp.php

This statement, I would say, shows good faith efforts by nic.ly to enforce their published policies.. which are available in english at http://nic.ly/regulations.php

There is only one registrar for .ly - Libya Telecom and Technology - and their website, and their policies, are in English.. http://www.ltt.ly/en/agents/l.php?service=2&city=1

To post comments, please login or create an account.

Related Blogs

Related News

Topics

Industry Updates – Sponsored Posts

LogicBoxes Partners With Domains.Green to Setup Retail & Wholesale Channels for .green Domains

New Top-Level Domain .fit Launches, Announces Partnership with the Arnold Sports Festival

Bauer Media Joins Minds + Machines as a .fishing Pioneer

New .vote TLD Used for Arizona Voters

First Premium .yoga Domains Up for Auction

Afilias Releases 160,000+ Names Across 8 New TLDs

Deal Yourself In: .POKER Names Now Open to All

Lou Andreozzi to Lead New .Law Top-Level Domain

ICANN Business Constituency Elects Elisa Cooper of MarkMonitor as Chair

PIR Releases Report Detailing Steady Growth of .org Domain in 2014

.film to Provide New Home Online for the Film Industry

.VOTE Solves Presidential Candidate Ted Cruz's Domain Name Problem

.green Now in General Availability

ICANN's Registry Audits Begin Next Week. Are You Prepared?

Sunrise Period Begins for .NGO and .ONG

.study & .courses to Launch with Support of ARI Registry Services

We Know This .Sucks

DotConnectAfrica on "CONNECTing the Dots: Options for Future Action" at UNESCO, Paris

ARI Registry Services Expands Middle East & Africa Operations

Radix Assumes Full Ownership of .online

Sponsored Topics

dotMobi

Mobile

Sponsored by
dotMobi
Verisign

Security

Sponsored by
Verisign
Afilias

DNS Security

Sponsored by
Afilias
Minds + Machines

Top-Level Domains

Sponsored by
Minds + Machines