Home / Blogs

Absolutely No Wireless Spectrum Shortage in 2010

Dave Burstein

Sure the iPhone has problems, but John Stankey of AT&T thinks restoring a $2B capex cut will fix them. It may take a little more money than that, but Glen Campbell of Merrill Lynch has confirmed he's on track. In a 50 page report that's one of the best I've read in years, Merrill destroyed the common belief that wireless has a significant spectrum shortage. He estimated the likely traffic demands (including iPhone) through 2012 (and possibly longer) and the realistic capabilities of the technology. AT&T and O2 obviously have to catch up some investment, but Campbell concludes "For most wireless carriers, we expect that capex increases will be temporary and/or modest ... network equipment cost declines will continue." He reviewed AT&T's plans to fix things and a myriad of technology moves already beginning that improve voice and data performance.

Off the record, two of the best engineers in the world have confirmed to me that's perfectly plausible. It corresponds to my research, an FCC conclusion, and what John Stankey of AT&T is telling investors.

Campbell calculates it costs less than $3/month for a gigabyte of added capacity, falling. If the average "unlimited" (really 5 gig) customer uses about 1 ½ gig (a likely average), that means a carrier collecting $20-50/month needs to spend about $5 of that for the bandwidth.

It should fit in a capex budget similar to todays and will drop with Moore's Law.

An important point is that the carriers can essentially control the bandwidth demand by plans and pricing. If they stay with today's 5 gigabyte cap or even double it, the numbers work. Behind the higher estimates for 2012-2015 is an implicit assumption that carriers will raise double their caps every two years and be at 20-40 gigabytes for the almost all customers. That's unlikely.

Those caps will limit the use of wireless for folks who want to watch all their TV over the net. It is therefore only a partial substitute for landlines, so I believe most families will maintain both. With a landline in most homes, 30-50% of wireless traffic can be diverted to femtos and WiFi. Vodafone and AT&T are well along making that happen, especially as femto prices drop to $50 and eventually $20. They pay for themselves just with the spectrum savings. Vodafone is already giving them out for free as part of the bundle and 2Wire has promised gateways with femtos inside.

While some of his conclusions are U.S. centric, most of his data applies across the world. Glen is Merrill's world lead on telecom and he has some conclusions about both the emerging and developed world. He has long been acknowledged as one of the dozen best in the world. This report is the most interesting I've seen in a while. It should be available through the standard investor databases but unfortunately is not public.

There are predictable technology shifts like double or triple capacity in 3G/4G, huge IP voice efficiencies that will free up spectrum used for voice today, mass deployment of WiFi phones and/or femtocells.

My guess is we probably can go a decade without a serious problem based on some almost certain FCC moves. Improved spectrum use is the most important part of the broadband plan, as I wrote more than a year ago.

By Dave Burstein, Editor, DSL Prime. Dave Burstein has edited DSL Prime and written about broadband and Internet TV for a decade.

Related topics: Broadband, Mobile, Telecom, White Space, Wireless

WEEKLY WRAP — Get CircleID's Weekly Summary Report by Email:


What Campbell actually says Richard Bennett  –  Feb 15, 2010 7:26 PM PDT

Here's what the Campbell report actually says:

We expect the toll road for mobile data will remain in place, with usage based pricing (or usage caps) and traffic prioritization. We see no alternatives to manage what would otherwise be insatiable demand growth. We expect a retreat from unlimited smartphone data offerings, particularly as carriers understand (and negotiate non-exclusive arrangements for) the iPhone. As data traffic grows and voice is increasingly carried as packet data, we see increasing need for data traffic prioritization (and a strong argument against heavy-handed net neutrality policies).

As long as operators are permitted to manage, spectrum crunch is no big deal; tie their hands to "all packets are equal" rules, all of a sudden you've got wireless meltdown. That's a big deal.

To post comments, please login or create an account.

Related Blogs

Related News

Explore Topics

Industry Updates – Sponsored Posts

Mobile Web Intelligence Report: Bots and Crawlers May Represent up to 50% of Web Traffic

Best Practices from Verizon - Proactively Mitigating Emerging Fraudulent Activities

The Latest Mobile Web Report Q4 2015 from DeviceAtlas

2015 Trends: Multi-channel, Streaming Media and the Growth of Fraud

DeviceAtlas Brings Device Awareness to HAProxy

DeviceAtlas Granted Patent on Device Detection Accuracy Method

SpotXchange Chooses DeviceAtlas to Target Ads to Specific Devices

5 Ways Google Brillo Can Change the Device Landscape

Sophia Bekele's Keynote Speech on "Africa: The Next Frontier for Mobile Technology"

Standards and Browser Compatibility

36 Must-Know Mobile Market Statistics For 2014

Mobile Web Traffic: A Dive Into the Data

Mobile Web Has Now Overtaken PC in 40 Nations, Including India, Nigeria and Bangladesh

Nominum Announces Future Ready DNS

New Chinese "Mobile" Top-Level Domain Now Available

Ofcom Benchmarking UK Broadband Performance Welcomed, But Needs Considerable Improvement

Join dotMobi at World Hosting Days 2014, April 1 - 3

Afilias Announces Its First Internationalized TLD With the Launch of .MOBILE in Chinese

dotMobi and Verio Introduce goMobi Mobile Website Solution in Europe

dotMobi and Verio introduce goMobi mobile website solution in Europe

Sponsored Topics

Afilias - Mobile & Web Services


Sponsored by
Afilias - Mobile & Web Services


Sponsored by

DNS Security

Sponsored by


Sponsored by