Home / Blogs

When Domain Names Aren't Enough

Paul Hoffman

A recent trend in the Japanese web advertising market may presage changes that could come to the Western world. As described here, some advertising in Japan now includes a picture of a filled-in browser search box instead of a domain name. The idea is that an advertiser can buy top-of-page advertising at the main search engines for various terms and then suggest to people reading their print ads to use those terms to search.

This strategy takes advantage of the simple fact that most people simply type into the search bar instead of the address bar. If you can control what they see on the first page of the search results, you have a good chance of getting them to your web site.

Of course, this strategy also has some huge downsides. First, you need to advertise on al the popular search sites for the duration of your "search for this" ads. Even if you do that, a canny competitor might buy ads for the same words in order to siphon off your viewers. Unless you are a huge advertiser, you cannot control the top of enough of the search engines to make this a sure-fire strategy. Sticking to good old domain names is safer, although it has the cost of knowing that people typically type them in the wrong place in their browsers.

By Paul Hoffman. Visit the blog maintained by Paul Hoffman here.

Related topics: DNS, Domain Names

WEEKLY WRAP — Get CircleID's Weekly Summary Report by Email:

Comments

Re: When Domain Names Aren't Enough Suresh Ramasubramanian  –  Mar 31, 2007 7:29 AM PST

For once, the japanese are behind the curve.

Pill spammers routinely send out image spam that's a screenshot of a browser, with a URL (the pill spam URL) typed in, and the URL is circled in red.

There's hashbusting dots or other pattern breakers in there too, to confuse image recognition filters.

Re: When Domain Names Aren't Enough Frank Schilling  –  Apr 02, 2007 7:42 AM PST

Agree with Suresh.  I've seen the subway video on IDN websites..  Advertising billboards feature a search box filled in with japanese characters.. that is how you should navigate.

How are you going to send the business email through that searchbox is beyond me. I think that dynamic was born out frustration at not having early access to International Domain Names. You can enter local characters into a search-box but you can't enter them into the address bar. Also some brand boasting: "Look, we're legitimate! you can find us in the leading engines!"

Then again maybe its a cultural difference.  Leasehold real estate works in some countries but freehold is the benchmark in the US centric world.  Would you rather build your brand by advertising a search engine's platform or would you rather own the platform by owning the name?

Re: When Domain Names Aren't Enough George Kirikos  –  Apr 02, 2007 9:33 AM PST

It's not just a Japanese trend, though. I've seen US television ads from big companies like Pontiac where they say "go to Google (or Yahoo) and search for Pontiac." Very odd.

On the other hand, you've got savvy people who switched from, say, IdolOnFox.com to AmericanIdol.com instead, and also defensively register the domains of their future stars.

Re: When Domain Names Aren't Enough Suresh Ramasubramanian  –  Apr 02, 2007 4:44 PM PST

Hold on, are we talking about IDN keywords here?  That's very very old, in Japan / Korea.  And there's enough vendors there with enough market share that they're not the happiest of campers at IDN coming along to put them all out of business.

For example, take a look at this one single post that "Jason S" ever made on circleid .. bashing IDNs in favor of keywords, with lots of vague words about impending legal action.

http://www.circleid.com/posts/do_we_really_need_idn/

The only thing he forgot to mention, and that several circleid posters mentioned for him, that he was personal assistant to a korean keyword company's CEO.

To post comments, please login or create an account.

Related Blogs

Related News

Topics

Industry Updates – Sponsored Posts

Top Level Domain Holdings Raises $14M for New gTLDs

.ORG COO Discusses Priorities With DailyVista, Pursuit of .NGO Domain

StarHub to Acquire '.starhub' New Top-Level Domain

ARI Registry Services Signs 21 Contracts in the First Week of New TLD Applications

MarkMonitor to Exhibit at Internet Tech Policy Exhibition and Reception to be Held on Capitol Hill

Sedari Signs With Dot Moscow Bidders

.ORG, The Public Interest Registry Welcomes Nancy Gofus As Chief Operating Officer

Minds+Machines Works with .bayern

The New Domain For Japan, JP.NET, Launches With Exclusive Invitation to Trademark Owners

Being a .PRO When Choosing a Registry Services Partner

UK Cabinet Office Looks to BlueCat Networks' Expertise and Best Practices for Securing PSN

Afilias Acquires Registry Services Corporation, .PRO

Thoughts on Applying for a Generic Top-Level Domain

Sedari Launches "Guess the Numbers Game" for New TLD Program

dot Brand Makes Its Debut: Afilias Advises Companies to Act Now for Successful TLD Applications

BlueCat Networks Helps Organizations Transition to IPv6 with HP

BlueCat Networks to Host Webinar on DNS, DHCP and IPAM Featuring Independent Research Firm

Facets of gTLD Registry Technical Operations - Registry Services

Technology and Finance Industries to Dominate New gTLD Applications

.CO Internet Selects Sedo to Broker Previously Unreleased .CO Domain Names

Hot Topics

Afilias

DNSSEC

Sponsored by
Afilias
Neustar UltraDNS

DNS

Sponsored by
Neustar UltraDNS
dotMobi

Mobile

Sponsored by
dotMobi
Verisign

Security

Sponsored by
Verisign
Minds + Machines

Top-Level Domains

Sponsored by
Minds + Machines