Home / Blogs

GeoTLDs: Diversity is Key

Werner Staub

The 2004 new sTLD round brought about a new type of TLD in the form of .asia and .cat. As we always struggle for words to capture their nature, I call them "geoTLDs". Culture, language and ethnicity are also part of geography.

Contrary to ccTLDs, geoTLDs do not have a territorial meaning. They are a wonderful addition to the Internet as they provide a way to demonstrate one's commitment to a community that is not defined by borders, yet linked to where the individual chooses to be.

A number of language communities have come forward and describe the strings they propose. Have a look at .cym, .sco, .gal or .bzh. Other initiatives are regional, such as .lac, for cities, such as .berlin or .nyc. GeoTLDs will be a significant component of the next TLD introduction phase, I believe.

Will they be? They will, unless we do the wrong thing now.

Feed them to the speculators, or send them down the infinite loop?

Initially, the discussion in the GNSO PDP oscillated between these extremes.

One mistake would be to send geoTLD applications to an infinite loop. And indeed, at the Wellington ICANN meeting, one proposal went as far as to say: "we cannot define any policy on place names". That is the infinite loop. Who else will ever define a policy?

The other mistake would be hand them out to the cyber-real-estate developer with the deepest pockets. This was indeed implied in the first consensus for the first-come-first-served approach on the TLD level. Speculators can move swiftly, communities have to do their homework. Taken literally, first-come-first-served implies that the natural community of a Geo name wouldn't have a chance against a speculator.

Emerging consensus? The TLD community matters

During the Amsterdam meeting of the GNSO council, significant progress was made to establish a relationship between the TLD string and its community — or its communities. The idea is to use the concept of community support. For the time being, this merely appears as a way to deal with contention.

Deriving the TLD requirements from the meaning of the string

Of course that is only a first attempt to find a wording. I believe that we should not look for a single generically phrased principle, across all types of TLDs. The criteria must depend on the meaning of the TLD string, at least in the case of geoTLDs. It is obvious that an international city name cannot be subject to the same criteria as the name of a small town. Nor can the name of a large ethnic or cultural group be treated like the name of a domestic animal.

Dirk Krischenowski from dotBerlin and I have worked a bit on that approach. Rather than throwing all geoTLDs in the same basket, we propose to look at the properties of each name. In the case of geoTLDs, this leads to about half a dozen key properties. From each property, it is relatively easy to derive the logical requirements. If a name matches more than one property, a TLD proposal to use it should obviously satisfy all the requirements.

As a byproduct, the line that separates ccTLD-IDN from gTLD-IDN

The meaning-based approach also helps differentiate between gTLDs and ccTLDs in the case of IDN.IDN TLDs. A given IDN string may be a popular name or abbreviation for an ISO-3166 territory. If its meaning matches the territory, one can safely regard the string as an IDN equivalent of a ccTLD. How this should be handled is of course up to the relevant community, and logically subject to ccTLD principles. If the meaning is not congruent to that of a country code, then it can be treated as a gTLD that must satisfy the requirements linked to its meaning.

All this is to say that geoTLDs have a big role to play thanks to their diversity. Diversity solves problems. We don't have to create it, it is there. We just have to take into account the meanings (mind the plural) of the TLD strings proposed.

By Werner Staub

Related topics: DNS, ICANN, Top-Level Domains


Don't miss a thing – get the Weekly Wrap delivered to your inbox.


Re: GeoTLDs: Diversity is Key Stephane Bortzmeyer  –  Sep 12, 2006 1:55 AM PDT

The link to your proposal written with Dirk Krischenowski from dotBerlin yields a 404 "File not found".

Re: GeoTLDs: Diversity is Key Dirk Krischenowski  –  Sep 12, 2006 3:33 AM PDT

Sorry, but it seem that the whole ICANNWIKI is down today. Let's hope that it's online soon.


Re: GeoTLDs: Diversity is Key Dirk Krischenowski  –  Sep 12, 2006 11:02 PM PDT

The ICANNWiki is finally online again and our text is accessible now.

Re: GeoTLDs: Diversity is Key Jothan Frakes  –  Sep 14, 2006 10:19 PM PDT

ICANNWiki was down briefly, but is up and running now and has lots of good information on GeoTLDs.

To post comments, please login or create an account.

Related Blogs

Related News

Explore Topics

Dig Deeper


Sponsored by Verisign

IP Addressing

Sponsored by Avenue4 LLC

Mobile Internet

Sponsored by Afilias Mobile & Web Services

DNS Security

Sponsored by Afilias

Promoted Posts

Buying or Selling IPv4 Addresses?

ACCELR/8 is a transformative IPv4 market solution developed by industry veterans Marc Lindsey and Janine Goodman that enables organizations buying or selling blocks as small as /20s to keep pace with the evolving demands of the market by applying processes that have delivered value for many of the largest market participants. more»

Industry Updates – Sponsored Posts

Domain Registrations Reach 331.9 Million, 6.7 Million Growth Year over Year

.brands Spotlight: Banking and Finance Industries

Google Buys Business.Site Domain for 'Google My Business'

Radix Announces Global Web Design Contest, F3.space

Global Domain Name Registrations Reach 330.6 Million, 1.3 Million Growth in First Quarter of 2017

.TECH Gets Its Big Hollywood Break

.PRESS Supports Press Freedom Day for 3rd Consecutive Year

5 Afilias Top Level Domains Now Licensed for Sale in China

Radix Announces Largest New gTLD Sale with Casino.Online

2016 Year in Review: The Trending Keywords in .COM and .NET Domain Registrations

Global Domain Name Registrations Reach 329.3 Million, 2.3 Million Growth in Last Quarter of 2016

A Look at How the New .SPACE TLD Has Performed Over the Past 2 Years

Neustar to be Acquired by Private Investment Group Led by Golden Gate Capital

Startup League Reports from WebSummit, Lisbon

.SPACE Becomes the Choice of the First Ever Space Nation Asgardia

Afilias Chairman Jonathan Robinson Wins ICANN's 2016 Leadership Award at ICANN 57

MarkMonitor Supports Brand Holders' Efforts Regarding .Feedback Registry

Don't Gamble With Your DNS

Why .com is the Venture Capital Community's Power Player

The .cancerresearch TLD: Search for Cure Drives Digital Innovation