|
CircleID is a community hub for the Internet Infrastructure |
Learn More Login | Sign Up | About CircleID |
Home / blogsMore on the Front Running Class Action Suit
Feb 28, 2008 8:33 AM PST
| Comments: 1
 Several people pointed out that although the suit still hasn’t appeared in PACER, copies of the complaint are available online, including this one [PDF] at Lextext. Having read it, I’m rather underwhelmed. After the usual lengthy enumeration of alleged misdeeds, the complaint charges Network Solutions (NSI) with fraudulent concealment, and unjust enrichment, while charging ICANN with aiding and abetting fraudulent concealment. I do not purport to be a lawyer (nor do I usually play one on the net), but it’s hard to see how the facts, which are not in serious dispute, would support any of these charges. Fraudulent concealment generally involves hiding important information when entering into a contract, e.g., not mentioning your three prior heart attacks when you get life insurance. But at the time the front running happens, when you search for a domain on NSI’s web site, there’s no contract, and you are entirely free not to buy the domain you searched for if you don’t like the price. Also, NSI now discloses on their home page that they may reserve the domains people search for, which means that even if they used to conceal something, they don’t do it any more. The unjust enrichment is slightly more plausible but still doesn’t fit the facts very well, since unjust enrichment typically occurs when the defendant was overpaid by accident, and the only remedy is restitution, returning the overpayment. If I were looking for a charge to fit these facts, I’d claim fraud or tortious interference with the registrant’s ability to buy from other registrars, but since I’m not a lawyer, what do I know? Another interesting aspect of this the lead plaintiff, Chris McElroy. He is a colorful character from Miami, a long term ICANN participant, who calls himself Namecritic, runs a blog for hire service and has attracted a certain amount of criticism of his own. But his long involvement with ICANN and Internet domains makes him an unusually poor lead defendant — how can a guy who’s been doing this for a decade turn around and claim he has no idea how registrars work? This suit is unlikely to go anywhere, but assuming it survives the certain defense motion for summary judgment, the discovery will be interesting. Source Credit: This has been a featured post from John Levine, Author, Consultant & Speaker. To learn more, visit this participant's full profile page.
More Under: DNS 
Stay Updated: To receive weekly email updates from CircleID sign up here or see the list of RSS feeds and mobile version of this site. Comments |
Start Your AdAds
Sponsored LinksMarketplaceIndustry UpdatesMay 17, 2008 5:28 PM PSTHostway to Offer Cable Companies Additional Revenue Streams at NCTA’s Cable Show ‘08
By Hostway |
Views: 12
May 15, 2008 11:28 AM PSTOverstock.com Chooses NeuStar’s UltraDNS for Managed DNS Service
By NeuStar |
Views: 137
May 14, 2008 11:37 AM PSTInside Your Domain Portfolio
By Sedo |
Views: 162
May 14, 2008 11:32 AM PSTSedo at Domain Roundtable 2008, San Francisco
By Sedo |
Views: 160
May 14, 2008 11:27 AM PSTSedo’s New Brokerage Application
By Sedo |
Views: 205
May 13, 2008 3:00 PM PSTICANN Unanimously Approves RegistryPro Proposal to Expand the .Pro TLD
By Hostway |
Views: 317
May 06, 2008 10:16 AM PSTOversee.net’s DomainSponsor Presents 3rd Annual DOMAINfest Global
By DomainSponsor |
Views: 526
May 02, 2008 10:21 AM PST.NL Auction Sneak Peak!
By Sedo |
Views: 597
Apr 30, 2008 10:01 AM PSTdotMobi Requests Proposals for find.mobi
By dotMobi |
Views: 811
Apr 28, 2008 2:08 PM PSTdotMobi Offers Prime Selection of Generic Domain Names to Spur Mobile Web Growth
By dotMobi |
Views: 1046
Start Your AdAds |
Hostway will participate in the National Cable & Telecommunications Association's Cable Show '08 as an exhibitor offering attendees additional revenue streams through its white label Web hosting program. 
NeuStar, Inc. has announced that Overstock.com, a popular online closeout retailer, has chosen NeuStar's UltraDNS Managed DNS Service to provide Overstock.com with a global DNS infrastructure that significantly enhances end-user experience and operational security -- and protects revenue in the highly competitive online retail market. 
We've seen a lot of changes in the domain industry over the last year, some positive, some challenging. Whether you're an old pro or just beginning, this spring is a great time to take inventory and make sure your domain business is on the right track for success this year and beyond. 
The third annual DOMAINfest Global, the premier conference and networking event for the domain name industry, will be held at the Renaissance Hollywood Hotel in Hollywood, California from January 28-30, 2009. Event registration will open later this year. 
dotMobi today announced that is accepting proposals for find.mobi, a consumer-facing mobile search tool; find.mobi was created by dotMobi's research and development team to demonstrate an operational mobile search engine that made the most of the mobile web and needs of on-the-go users. |
Sitemap: Overview | Home | Desktop | RSS | Email | Mobile About CircleID: Overview | Media Coverage | CircleID Blog | Advertise | Contact Codes of Conduct | Privacy Policy | Terms of Use Copyright © 2002-2008 CircleID & Iomemo, Inc. All rights reserved unless where otherwise noted. |
 DNS Powered by NeuStar |
 Managed Hosting by Hostway |
Nice of you to link to an article and blog that one disgruntled employee wrote. Of course the negative information helps you forward the points you are trying to make in the article.
Since I have been doing business on the web since 1995 and have one person who did this, I’d say that is not a bad track record.
Your pointing out of that negative information is a pretty cheap way to try to make your point.
I notice you didn’t bother linking to archives that show my participation in the ICANN process over the years or the fact that I run a real missing children’s organization where I have personally helped to find more than 80 missing children.
No mention of the fact that I am not doing this to make money. Those who know me already know this. Perhaps you’ve never done something to get policy changed rather than just to make money. I don’t know.
I’ve been an activist for a long time. ICANN does not listen to anything said in public forums or mailing lists. Other action needs to be taken.
In addition to that I do a little more than just run a blog for hire service, which you phrased that way in another attempt at making me appear as a fringe element of some sort.
You say you aren’t a lawyer, then go on to try and discredit the legal merits of the lawsuit as if you were.
Since the law firm in question has won a lot of cases involving consumer protection in the past, I’ll let them give me legal advice rather than you. I’m sure you will understand as soon as you look past your own ego.
You did actually miss the point of the lawsuit and ICANN’s inclusion in it altogether, but since your goal was misinformation and to discredit, then it really doesn’t matter.
Do you consider self-importance a flaw in your character or an attribute?
I cannot comment directly about the details or merits of the case. I wish I could so that I could try get you to do a more than just writea narrow opinion based on one point of view.