Home / Blogs

Registrars That Complied With "Shakedown" Requests May Now Be in Violation of ICANN Transfers Policy

Mark Jeftovic

At the time we posted 'Whatever Happened To Due Process,' we were unaware that we were just one of many registrars receiving these notices from the London (UK) Police.

We have since been made aware that this was part of a larger initiative against the BitTorrent space as a whole, and that most if not all of the other registrars in receipt of the same email as us folded rather quickly and acquiesced to the shakedown orders.

Since there were no charges against any of the domains and no court orders, it may be at the registrars' discretion to play ball with these ridiculous demands. However — what they clearly cannot do now, is prevent any of those domain holders from simply transferring out their names to more clueful, less wimpy registrars.

City of London Police Shakedown Request in ProgressIf any of those registrars denied the ability to do that, then they would be in clear violation of the ICANN Inter-Registrars Transfer Policy.

Section 3, Obligations of The Registrar of Record clearly spells out the reasons why a registrar may deny a transfer-out request, and they are limited specifically to cases of fraud (the domain was paid for fraudulently), a UDRP proceeding or, hey, get this one "Court order by a court of competent jurisdiction", as well as some administrative reasons (like the domain was registered less than 60 days ago).

What is clearly absent from the list of reasons why a registrar of one of these torrent sites that has been taken offline by this, is "because some guy sent you an email telling you to lock it down".

Any registrar that has taken one of these sites offline that now impedes the registrants of those domains from simply getting their domain names out of there and back online somewhere else will then be subject to the TDRP — Transfer Dispute Resolution Policy and if they lose (which they will) they will be subject to TDRP fees assessed by the registry operator, and to quote the TDRP itself "Transfer dispute resolution fees can be substantial".

This is why it is never a good idea to just react to pressure in the face of obnoxious bluster — in the very act of trying to diffuse any perceived culpability you end up opening yourself to real liability.

Even when Verisign seizes a domain out from under you (like they did one of ours earlier this year ) it at least happens under a "sealed warrant" — blessing it with a veneer of Soviet-Era style legality.

By Mark Jeftovic, Co-Founder, easyDNS Technlogies Inc.. More blog posts from Mark Jeftovic can also be read here.

Related topics: Domain Names, Registry Services, ICANN, Law

WEEKLY WRAP — Get CircleID's Weekly Summary Report by Email:

Comments

It's all about ".com" Jurisdiction & Venue. Graham Schreiber  –  Oct 11, 2013 11:53 AM PDT

London Police would know that they're acting on behalf of a United States agency; and anything / anybody acting unfavourably with a ".com" TLD is subject to the "long arm" of US Law.

See: http://www.law.cornell.edu/wex/long-arm_statute

ICANN function under the NTIA and are obliged to protect American Interests.

This would be more complicated if the offences were being done by an ICANN / ccNSO approved ccTLD, such as .CA or .UK; because, the National Laws of any Country govern that Internet real estate.

Cheers.

To post comments, please login or create an account.

Related Blogs

Related News

Topics

Industry Updates – Sponsored Posts

ICANN London Recap Webinar

Four Reasons to Move from .COM to Your .BRAND Domain

Introducing the New .ORGANIC Domain: A Trusted, Credible Space for Organic Products on the Web

.WANG - 15,000 Registrations on Day One of General Availability

Dot Brand: Why Your Brand Needs Its Own Top-Level Domain

Afilias Announces Start of .BLACK Sunrise Period

Radix Launches Three New TLDs in Sunrise With Backing from 50+ Registrar Partners

.WANG General Availability Opens on June 30, 2014

Continuing to Work in the Public Interest

.Press Domain Names - The Changing Face of Journalism

LogicBoxes Waives Upfront Fees for New gTLD Vertical Integration Solutions

Radix Announces .Website Launch Timeline

.Host Timeline Released As Pioneer Program Kicks Off

TLD Registry Sponsored Xinnet's Partner Conference in Nanjing

Afilias Selected for CIO 100 Award

Victorian Government & ARI Agree to Long-Term .melbourne Partnership

.WANG Enters Landrush This Week

Public Interest Registry Offers New Internationalized Domain Names to General Public

Dot NYC (.nyc) TLD Enters First Phase of Launch

ARI Registry Services Facilitates Delegation of Another .brand TLD

Sponsored Topics