Home / Blogs

Now That Kurt Pritz Has Resigned over Conflict of Interest, Will a Transparent Investigation Follow?

Khaled Fattal

Yesterday ICANN announced that its new CEO Fadi Chehade accepted ICANN Chief Strategy Officer Kurt Pritz's resignation over conflict of Interests — will a transparent investigation follow? Otherwise, what else and what next?

In a statement on its ICANN website, Fadi Chehade states: "Kurt has submitted his resignation because of a recently identified conflict of interest". Prior to his weeks old role as Chief Strategy Officer Mr. Pritz was the top ICANN Executive overseeing the New gTLDs program.

ICANN has not disclosed the nature of the conflict nor whether is it limited and personal to only Mr. Pritz or if it is linked to any third party or parties inside or outside ICANN.

ICANN is yet to indicate if an investigation is being considered and whether such an investigation is best to be undertaken internally or externally to control the damage to its image, reputation, credibility and legitimacy worldwide and as the beacon of the Multi-stakeholder model less than 3 weeks before the World Conference on International Telecommunications (WCIT) convenes and where its role under the singular mandate of the United States Government and the current internet governance models are key topics to be debated and decided on.

It is yet to be determined if this is part of a deliberate drive by Mr. Chehade to reform and restructure ICANN above and beyond the operational excellence he identified as part of his plan and which cannot succeed without cleansing ICANN transparently from its conflict of interest woes.

No detail yet has been conveyed if any internal or external third party(s) are involved, nor whom they may be.

Similarly ICANN has not disclosed the nature of the interest that led to Mr. Pritz's resignation and if other staff members or anyone on the ICANN board itself are involved directly or indirectly, or whether this conflict of interest is limited to only Mr. Pritz.

Worth noting is that concerns over widespread conflicts of interests inside ICANN including its board are not new and have been raised against the organization over many years.

Most recently ICANN's former Chairman Mr. Peter Dengate Thrush who led ICANN for three years and guided it over the New gTLD program joined a major applicant group for new gTLDs immediately after his term as ICANN chairman ended which seriously damaged ICANN's credibility and legitimacy worldwide. It also highlighted and identified how poor and inadequate ICANN's bylaws that govern conflicts of interests are and how challenged its current structures are in effectively serving the Global Public Interest, the Multi stakeholder model, and in delivering on their global internet mandated role with real transparency, credibility and legitimacy.

So will we witness a damage control publicity campaign in response to this new revelation or has has Real "Change" Come to ICANN?

All these above question have been put formally to ICANN to respond to. Ankabooot will publish them as soon as they are received.

This Ankabooot editorial first appeared on this page.

By Khaled Fattal, Group Chairman, The Multilingual Internet Group. Visit the blog maintained by Khaled Fattal here.

Related topics: ICANN

WEEKLY WRAP — Get CircleID's Weekly Summary Report by Email:

Comments

mountain.....molehill McTim  –  Nov 17, 2012 8:30 AM PDT

Hi Khaled,

I think your call for an investigation is not only premature, but over the top.

Why on earth would you suspect that anyone else is involved?  This sounds like a simple case where we should celebrate the openness and candor of ICANN staff, and not look for conspiracies where there is no suggestion of one.

I think this announcement increases ICANN's "image, reputation, credibility and legitimacy worldwide" rather than threatens it!

Regards,

McTim

And I agree with McTim Suresh Ramasubramanian  –  Nov 19, 2012 8:34 PM PDT

It would also be utterly unwise for ICANN to make any employee firing related decisions more public than the brief note that was released to cover Pritz's removal.

To post comments, please login or create an account.

Related Blogs

Related News

Topics

Industry Updates – Sponsored Posts

DotConnectAfrica Trust Responds to ICANN GAC Objection Advice on Its .Africa Application

Radix Registry Passes 4 New gTLD Initial Evaluations

.PW Crosses 50,000 Domain Registrations in 3 Weeks

DotConnectAfrica Participates at the ICANN 46 International Meeting in Beijing, China

dot Brand or dot What? Consumers Unaware of New TLDs, Including .Google, .Microsoft and .Nike

Zodiac Prepares for Chinese New gTLDs, Announces "Chinese Advisory Services" for New gTLD Applicants

DotConnectAfrica Clarified Its .africa Bid at the Innovation Africa Digital Summit in Addis Ababa

.PW General Availability Opens With More Than 4000 Orders in 30 Minutes

CentralNic Powers First New Top-Level Domains Announced by ICANN

Invitation to a Seminar on "A New Beginning - Domain Name Market in China"

LogicBoxes Announces Vertical Integration Solutions for New gTLDs

IBCA Called for Inclusion of African Businesses at ICANN Africa Strategy Meeting in Addis Abeba

DCA Registry Services Participates in ICANN Africa Strategy Meeting, Addis Ababa

gTLD Update: No TLDH or Client Strings Affected

Public Interest Registry Opens Call for Expressions of Interest for .NGO & .ONG Domain Registrations

Industry Veteran Wang Jian Joins Zodiac Holdings Ltd as Chief Operating Officer

2012: A Year in Review, End of Year Message from DotConnectAfrica

gTLD Update: Results of the Prioritization Draw

DotConnectAfrica Participates in ICANN Lottery Draw Ranking 1005 for .africa - A Historic Milestone

Religion, Tech and Automotive Sectors Get the Luck of the Draw in New Top-Level Domain Program

Sponsored Topics

dotMobi

Mobile

Sponsored by
dotMobi
Minds + Machines

Top-Level Domains

Sponsored by
Minds + Machines
Neustar

DNS

Sponsored by
Neustar
Afilias

DNS Security

Sponsored by
Afilias