Home / Blogs

The Myth of the Unintended Infringer in SOPA and PIPA

Paul Vixie

In a recent op-ed piece in TheHill.COM, some friends and I described the futility of mandated DNS blocking as contemplated by the SOPA (H.R. 3261) and PIPA (S. 968) bills now working their way through the U.S. Congress:

No Internet user is required to use the Domain Name servers provided by their ISP. And if millions of American citizens who for whatever reason want to engage in online piracy can no longer do so because Congress has passed this law and their ISP is now filtering the citizen's DNS lookups, well, those citizens will have dozens if not thousands of off-shore Domain Name servers they can switch to with the click of a mouse.

This is an important point since if federal law is changed to mandate that hundreds of millions of dollars be spent by ISP's blocking the estimated hundred or so domain names used by the worst off-shore offenders of U. S. copyright and trademark law, then we'd all like to have some assurance that American consumers will respect this blockade. We would call those consumers "unintended infringers" because they are infringing U. S. copyrights and trademarks now, but are doing so in ignorance, and if they knew they were stealing, they wouldn't do it. We know that no "intended infringers" — who already know they are stealing when they buy pirated or infringing goods online — will be stopped by any federal law, since the Internet just doesn't work that way. From the same article:

The Great Firewall of China is built to a massive scale and could easily cope with this sort of problem. Since we in America would never monitor and restrict Internet traffic at that scale, the best Congress could hope for would be a symbolic gesture that merely indicates our country's displeasure with online piracy and infringement — without stopping such activities or even slowing them down by much.

Today I happened across a recent report from Cisco Systems entitled "Beg, Borrow or Steal? Young Professionals, College Students Admit They'll Go to Extreme Measures for Internet Access Despite IT Policies, Identity Theft Risks", which studies the infringement motives of a statistically meaningful population. Here's an excerpt:

"Of those who were aware of IT policies, seven of every 10 (70%) employees worldwide admitted to breaking policy with varying regularity. Among many reasons, the most common was the belief that employees were not doing anything wrong (33%). One in five (22%) cited the need to access unauthorized programs and applications to get their job done, while 19% admitted the policies are not enforced. Some (18%) said they do not have time to think about policies when they are working, and others either said adhering to the policies is not convenient (16%), they forget to do so (15%), or their bosses aren't watching them (14%)."

What this means from a high level policy perspective is that we really can put "unintended infringer" into the "myth" category.

By Paul Vixie, CEO, Farsight Security. More blog posts from Paul Vixie can also be read here.

Related topics: Access Providers, Censorship, DNS, Law, Policy & Regulation

WEEKLY WRAP — Get CircleID's Weekly Summary Report by Email:

Comments

To post comments, please login or create an account.

Related Blogs

Related News

Topics

Industry Updates – Sponsored Posts

The Latest Internet Plague: Random Subdomain Attacks

Digging Deep Into DNS Data Discloses Damaging Domains

Nominum Announces Future Ready DNS

Neustar to Launch usTLD Stakeholder Council

Dyn Acquires Internet Intelligence Company, Renesys

Introducing getdns: a Modern, Extensible, Open Source API for the DNS

Why We Decided to Stop Offering Free Accounts

Tony Kirsch Announced As Head of Global Consulting of ARI Registry Services

24 Million Home Routers Expose ISPs to Massive DNS-Based DDoS Attacks

Dyn Acquires Managed DNS Provider Nettica

Why Managed DNS Means Secure DNS

SPECIAL: Video Interviews from NamesCon 2014 in Las Vegas

Rodney Joffe on Why DNS Has Become a Favorite Attack Vector

DotConnectAfrica Attends Transform Africa 2013 Summit in Rwanda

Motivated to Solve Problems at Verisign

Dyn Announces Largest Quarter In Company History

Diversity, Openness and vBSDcon 2013

How Does Dyn Deliver on Powering the Internet? By Investing in Standards Organizations Like the IETF

Neustar's Proposal for New gTLD Collision Risk Mitigation

Dyn Announces the Opening of New Data Center in Mumbai, India

Sponsored Topics