Home / Blogs

The Jaynes Case is Finally Over

John Levine

Last September the Virginia Supreme Court issued a surprise ruling that reversed its previous decision and threw out the state's anti-spam law on First Amendment grounds. The Commonwealth made a last ditch appeal to the US Supreme Court, which I predicted they'd be unlikely to accept. I guessed right, they turned it down yesterday, meaning the case is finally over.

Due to the peculiar facts and history of this case, the decision would be unlikely ever to affect anyone other than Jaynes, and he's still in jail on other charges, so in the big picture it's just a blip. I thought the VA legislature had already passed a revised law that fixed the first amendment problem, but apparently not, since the state Attorney General says he's drafting a new law for next year's session. Even that's not all that important, since state laws are tightly constrained by CAN SPAM, and can only make things that are already illegal under CAN SPAM more illegal. The most useful difference a state law can make is to leave out the CAN SPAM language about awarding costs which makes a losing CAN SPAM suit potentially very expensive to the plaintiff.

By John Levine, Author, Consultant & Speaker. More blog posts from John Levine can also be read here.

Related topics: Law, Spam

WEEKLY WRAP — Get CircleID's Weekly Summary Report by Email:

Comments

To post comments, please login or create an account.

Related Blogs

Related News

Topics

Industry Updates – Sponsored Posts

INTA 2013: Gearing Up for Dallas

Thomson Reuters to Acquire MarkMonitor

Nominum Launches Comprehensive Suite of DNS-Based Security Solutions for Russian Service Providers

Nominum Sets New Record for Network Speed and Efficiency

DNS on Defense, DNS on Offense

Managing Outbound Spam: A New DNS-based Approach For Stopping Abuse (Webinar)

MarkMonitor Fraud Intelligence Report, Q4 2011

Afilias Says "No" to SOPA

Minds + Machines to Announce New .brand gTLD Pricing at INTA

MarkMonitor Fraud Intelligence Report Released for Q2 2011

.CO Recognized Alongside Industry Giants in Trademark Industry Awards

Verisign and Coalition for ICANN Transparency, Inc. ("CFIT") Resolve Litigation

MarkMonitor to Co-Chair International Anti-Counterfeiting Coalition Spring Conference

The Botnet-Counterfeit Drugs Connection

Q4 2010 Fraud Intelligence Report

AusRegistry Int. and Crowell & Moring Join Forces to Support New Top-Level Domain Applicants

MarkMonitor Report: How Scammers Generate Significant Traffic Promoting Suspected Counterfeit Goods

Report Sheds Light on Scale and Complexity of Online Piracy and Counterfeiting Problem

Acquisition Extends Anti-Piracy Capabilities for Digital Content

How Targeting Luxury Brands Online Results in Significant Traffic for Online Scammers

Sponsored Topics