Home / News

Rising Concerns Over UN Anti-Cyberattack Plan: Could End Internet Anonymity

Recent reports suggest that the International Telecommunication Union (ITU), a United Nations agency, is "quietly drafting technical standards, proposed by the Chinese government," aimed at preventing Internet attacks which could also put an end to anonymity on the Internet.

At an up coming ITU meeting in Geneva next week, telecommunication experts will be discussing draft recommendation of "IP Traceback" use case and requirements, looking at ways to identify the source of packets sent across IP (Internet Protocol) networks.

Also posted on Dave Farber's public mailing list, Declan McCullagh has shared some additional findings as a result of speaking to various people involved at ITU and while preparing to write his article:

  • The ITU's Q6/17 group is meeting next week in Geneva with an eye to having a final document finished sometime in 2009 (though one editor told me it might take longer). The proceedings are not open to the public — I applied to attend and was rejected — and relatively few documents are public.
  • China's proposal submitted in April says the "IP traceback mechanism is required to be adapted to various network environments, such as different addressing (IPv4 and IPv6), different access methods (wire and wireless) and different access technologies (ADSL, cable, Ethernet) and etc." It adds: "To ensure traceability, essential information of the originator should be logged."
  • An ITU network security meeting a few years ago concluded that anonymity should not be permitted. The summary said: "Anonymity was considered as an important problem on the Internet (may lead to criminality). Privacy is required but we should make sure that it is provided by pseudonymity rather than anonymity."
  • An ITU presentation in July from Korea said that groups such as the IETF should be "required to develop standards or guidelines" that could "facilitate tracing the source of an attacker including IP-level traceback, application-level traceback, user-level traceback." Another Korean proposal — which has not been made public — says all Internet providers "should have procedures to assist in the lawful traceback of security incidents."

Read full story: CNET News

Related topics: Cyberattack, Cybercrime, Internet Governance, Privacy

WEEKLY WRAP — Get CircleID's Weekly Summary Report by Email:

Comments

My Computer != Me Chris Snyder  –  Sep 15, 2008 4:39 AM PST

You can (and sometimes should) trace bad actions to a source computer, but that doesn't actually prove anything. Given the sophistication of virus and botnet authors, and the relative weakness of consumer operating systems and application platforms to attack, people can't actually be held accountable for what happens on the computers they own or use.

You and your computer are separate entities. Even your cellphone, once thought to be as personal a computer as you can get, is a full-fledged consumer OS running third-party applications downloaded from the 'net.

Any actual policy or law based on removing anonymity from the Internet has to address the fact that there is no way, beyond circumstantial evidence, to "trace back" the actions of a computer to a particular human operator. Anything can be scripted, and no operator has perfect knowledge of what's happening in software.

To post comments, please login or create an account.

Related Blogs

Related News

Topics

Industry Updates – Sponsored Posts

MarkMonitor to Exhibit at Internet Tech Policy Exhibition and Reception to be Held on Capitol Hill

Afilias Says "No" to SOPA

2011: A Year in Review, from the Yes2DotAfrica Campaign

An Interview with DotConnectAfrica's Executive Director, Sophia Bekele

Yes2dotAfrica Campaign Triumphs at ICANN-42 Meeting in Dakar Senegal

Q3 2011 Fraud Intelligence Report

DotConnectAfrica Executive Briefing Note at the ICANN-42 Public Forum Meeting at Dakar, Senegal

SPECIAL: Updates from the ICANN Meetings in Dakar

The Spookiest DDoS Attacks in History

Protecting Your Business from DDoS Attacks: Advice from Neustar

The Global NGO Community and PIR at IGF

MarkMonitor Fraud Intelligence Report Released for Q2 2011

SPECIAL: Updates from the ICANN Meetings in Singapore

President Obama Names Neustar President and CEO Lisa Hook to NSTAC

Digital Hollywood Taps Domain Name Expert Ben Crawford for Insight on New Internet Policy

Businesses Lack Safeguards Against DDoS Attacks and DNS Failures, New Research Shows

Q1 2011 Fraud Intelligence Report

Neustar Launches SiteProtect for DDoS Protection

The Botnet-Counterfeit Drugs Connection

New Verisign Uptime Bundle Combines DDoS Protection, Managed DNS and Threat Intelligence Services

Hot Topics

Afilias

DNSSEC

Sponsored by
Afilias
Verisign

Security

Sponsored by
Verisign
dotMobi

Mobile

Sponsored by
dotMobi
Minds + Machines

Top-Level Domains

Sponsored by
Minds + Machines
Neustar UltraDNS

DNS

Sponsored by
Neustar UltraDNS