Home / Industry

Registry/Registrar Vertical Integration: The Registrant Pays the Check

In a joint document, Afilias, NeuStar, and PIR discuss the salient issues facing the ICANN Board regarding a proposal for registry/registrar vertical integration in the newTLD round.  The paper identifies some of the risks associated with the ICANN Staff proposal while at the same time proposing a path forward that does not jeopardize any further delay in the new generic Top-Level Domain (gTLD) launch process. A summary of the points raised includes:

  • Since its inception, it was clear that the vertical separation policy was serving consumer protection values that included — but went far beyond — competition.
  • Eliminating the vertical separation restraints under the current top down process could result in significant delay in the new TLD round.
  • Studies to date have not fully addressed how such a change would benefit consumers and registrants, nor have they included an analysis of the potential harm to domain name registrants of permitting registrars to operate as new gTLD registries while selling in their own string.
  • The vertically integrated registry/registrar will create an environment that is ripe for "insider trading" opportunities using data that is commercially sensitive and available uniquely to the registry operator.
  • Permitting vertically integrated registry/registrar operations will eliminate certain current penalties that discourage abusive practices.
  • Registrars are divided. "Right now, our industry has conflicts of interest and it is putting personal short-term gain ahead of long term commercial interests,' says Joe White at the Gandi registrar.
  • Since registry service providers or "backend" providers offer functionally equivalent services as registry operators, the application of existing policy to registry services providers is appropriate and necessary to effectuate the longstanding pro-competition and end user protection goals of the policy.
  • ICANN need not delay the new TLD round on the basis of the vertical separation issue. ICANN can proceed by continuing the policy of separation for registry operators and registry service providers in the new round while the community, if necessary, launches a PDP that can appropriately address the fundamental economic and registrant impact issues on a parallel track.

The longstanding vertical separation policy ensures important protections for registrants in a market that will soon include hundreds of newTLD choices. PIR, Neustar and Afilias welcome new competition in the TLD registry market by registrars as long as they are restrained from selling their own TLD and we support the RyC supermajority position on the CRAI Report. The current restraint against a registry distributing its own TLD should be maintained to avoid creating incentives to abuse registry data and to protect registrants and other registrars from unfair gaming of the registration system.

About PIR

PIR

Trusted across all ages, backgrounds and nationalities, .ORG is where people turn to find credible information, get involved, fund causes and support advocacy. .ORG, The Public Interest Registry empowers the global noncommercial community to use the Internet more effectively and, concurrently, takes a leadership position among Internet stakeholders on policy and related issues on behalf of the .ORG Community. (Learn More)

Related topics: Domain Names, Registry Services, ICANN, Policy & Regulation, Top-Level Domains

WEEKLY WRAP — Get CircleID's Weekly Summary Report by Email:

Related Blogs

Related News

Topics

Industry Updates – Sponsored Posts

General Availability Period for New .RED Top-Level Domain Opens

General Availability Period for New .BLUE Top-Level Domain Opens

General Availability Period for New .PINK Top-Level Domain Opens

New Chinese "Mobile" Top-Level Domain Now Available

New .KIM Domain Goes Live

Welcome .SHIKSHA! General Availability Now Open

Adrian Kinderis Appointed as Chair of Domain Name Association

Internet Reaches 271 Million Domain Names in the Fourth Quarter of 2013

The Future of Chinese Domain Names (a Panel Discussion)

dotStrategy Selects Neustar's Registry Threat Mitigation Services for .BUZZ Registry

Tony Kirsch Announced As Head of Global Consulting of ARI Registry Services

Afilias Chairman Appointed to Domain Name Association Board

.BUILD Enters Landrush with Support of ARI Registry Services

Radix Awards Contracts for .website, .host, .space, and .press to CentralNic plc

DotConnectAfrica Statement Regarding NTIA's Intent to Transition Key Internet Domain Name Function

Afilias Welcomes "Dot Chinese Online" and "Dot Chinese Website" Top-Level Domains to the Internet

Afilias Joins Internet Technical Leaders in Welcoming IANA Globalization Progress

Afilias Welcomes .ONL and .RICH to the Internet

Neustar Selected to Continue Administering the .US Domain

The Practicalities of a New Domain Launch

Sponsored Topics