I read, with some small amount of discomfort, an article by Bill Brenner on CSO Online, wherein he interviewed several other CSOs and other “Security Execs” on their opinions on the firing of Pennsylvania CISO Robert Maley. For those who haven’t heard about this, Mr. Maley was fired for talking about a security incident during the recent RSA conference without approval from his bosses.

The first thing that struck me was the “tow the line” posture by everyone interviewed—but then again, I agree that in such a position as Mr. Maley was in as CISO, it certainly violates certain aspects of confidentiality, etc., which his job may have required regarding such an incident.

The second thing that struck me, of course, was that if a mandatory U.S. National Breach Disclosure law existed, Mr. Maley would not have found himself in such a position to begin with.

Another issue which falls within this controversy are large corporations which try to keep secret the fact that they were involved in serious IT security breaches, and keep their customers in the dark.

We are seeing more and more cases of unauthorized information disclosure day after day, month after month, year over year in all areas—finance, health information and medical records, and other sorts of personal identity theft.

We are long overdue on a national breach disclosure law which makes it mandatory for companies and other organizations to publicly disclose these incidents have occurred. Long overdue.

I would appreciate hearing thoughts from readers on this issue—please leave your comments.